Old Georgetown Appendix: CFA Meeting — 21 February 2013

OG 12-171

HPA number
HPA 12-282
Property
Residence
Description
Three-story rear addition, in-fill areaway, one-story side addition, alterations
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation
Returned without Action. Although there is no objection to a general concept of additions and alterations to the building, the concept design, as proposed, was not approved. The case has been inactive for a period of time. File new submission of concept drawings, including details for the three-story addition in the character of an enclosed porch, for review by the Commission.

OG 12-308

HPA number
HPA 12-522
Property
Commercial / office
Description
Replacement windows
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
Recommend against issuance of permit for proposed removal of existing windows. Submitted materials are not sufficient for review. Case has been inactive for a period of time. File new submission of required information for replacement window proposals, including window survey, and existing and proposed details, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 12-323

HPA number
HPA 12-540
Property
Residence
Description
2-story + basement rear addition, raze garage and rebuild new garage at alley
Review Type
Permit - revised design
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for proposed revision to approved design for two-story rear addition with basement as shown in supplemental drawings dated 6 February 2013 which indicate a 3 5/8 inches offset of east wall of addition from the wall of the historic building. No objection to issuance of permit for replacement garage structure as shown in supplemental drawings dated 23 August 2012 which indicate wood garage door. There will be no rooftop mechanical equipment on house. Windows on front facade will be repaired. No objection to issuance of permit for razing of existing garage structure off rear alley. Note that the Capitol Trust holds an easement on this property. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit. File new submission of detailed and dimensioned drawings for the installation of solar panels with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-021

HPA number
HPA 13-039
Property
Commercial
Description
Alterations to storefront, sign scheme
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation

No objection to concept design for proposed alterations to storefront, including replacement of French doors for picture windows and new entry door as shown in supplemental drawings dated 24 January 2013 which indicate revisions to existing sign scheme to conform to previously approved design. See previous recommendation under case OG 11-253. File new submission of construction drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-042

HPA number
HPA 13-069
Property
Commercial
Description
Replacement windows
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
Recommend against issuance of permit for proposed replacement of windows with vinyl windows. Submitted materials are not sufficient for review. Case has been inactive for a period of time. File new submission of required information for replacement window proposals, including window survey, and existing and proposed details, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-048

HPA number
HPA 13-075
Property
Residence
Description
Replacement windows
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
Return without Action. Case has been inactive for a period of time. File new submission with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-050

HPA number
HPA 13-077
Property
Georgetown University – New South Student Center
Description
Site work and alterations
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation
No objection to proposed concept design for reconfiguration of street layout at Prospect Street and Tondorf Road with new stone retaining wall, guard booth, recessed loading dock, terraces, stairs, cable railings, and handicap ramp as well as alterations to New South including doors, windows, skylight, bronze screen, and bronze canopy as shown in supplemental drawings dated 31 January 2013. File new concept submission with developed design, including details and dimensions, for review by the Commission.

OG 13-054

HPA number
HPA 13-081
Property
Commercial
Description
Alterations to storefront
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation
No objection to concept design for proposed reconstruction of rear of building to match pre-collapse condition with new window well, and for alterations to storefront as shown in supplemental drawings dated 25 January 2013 which indicate ADA entrance, single light show windows, wood trim and sign panel, 2/2 windows on second floor, and four panel door. File new submission of working drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-055

HPA number
HPA 13-082
Property
Residence
Description
Replacement window, repair of 2/2 windows
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation

No objection to issuance of permit for the proposed replacement of the basement window with a 2/2 insulated wood window with a 1 1/4 inch true-divided-light muntin, and for the repair of the five 2/2 wood windows on front facade, which are original, as indicated in supplemental information dated 23 January 2013. Recommend use of interior storms. The replacement of the five 2/2 windows on front facade was not approved and was deleted from this permit application. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-057

HPA number
HPA 13-084
Property
Office building
Description
Alterations
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation
No objection to concept design for new vestibule with glass storefront system with stone paving as shown in supplemental drawings dated 24 January 2013 which indicate retention of two brick piers. Note all signage withdrawn from this application. File new submission of working drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-061

HPA number
HPA 13-096
Property
Commercial
Description
Sign and lighting for 'i-Thai'
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for three new lights, 1/2-inch-thick PVC lettering applied to trim reading 'i-Thai' at 10-inches tall and 'Restaurant and Sushi Bar' at 2.75-inches tall per drawings dated 13 February 2013, provided two existing metal brackets, flag brackets, and electrical conduit are all removed.

OG 13-062

HPA number
HPA 13-105
Property
Residence
Description
Wood pergola at rear
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for proposed pergola at rear yard as shown in supplemental drawings dated 7 February 2013 which indicate structure will be no larger than 8 feet by 13 feet and built of Western red cedar. The use of vinyl is not appropriate and was deleted from this permit application. Wood pergola must be painted or stained (solid) to match color of trim on back of house. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-063

HPA number
HPA 13-110
Property
Residence
Description
Repair planter wall on public space
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit to rebuild 2-3 course (only) brick retaining wall along 30th Street, recommend unpainted brick to match sidewalk brick.

OG 13-065

HPA number
HPA 13-115
Property
Commercial
Description
Lowering of exposed duct on roof
Review Type
Permit - revised design
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for proposed lowering of exposed rooftop duct to make it not visible from public thoroughfare as shown in supplemental drawings dated 28 January 2013. Proposed alterations to parapet with attachment of perforated metal screen were withdrawn from this permit application at the written request of applicant. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-066

HPA number
HPA 13-117
Property
Residences
Description
Solar panels
Review Type
Permit - revised design
Recommendation

Returned without Action. Submission materials and a site visit of 23 January indicate that the proposed addition of one solar panel to the previously approved installation will not be visible from a public thoroughfare. See previous recommendation under case OG 13-011 in which installation was located to minimize visibility. Refer to D.C. Historic Preservation Review Board.

OG 13-067

HPA number
HPA 13-118
Property
Mixed-use complex
Description
Sign scheme for 'Washington Harbour'
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for proposed sign scheme for Washington Harbour as shown in supplemental drawings dated 29 January and 14 February 2013, which include blade sign reading 'Park' at garage entrance with 'entrance' and 'exit' panels resting on piers at each end of opening, street numbers on monumental sign by vehicular circle, a directory at corner of building, and 'parking' signs at lower plaza. Oversized back-lit letters on windows were not approved and were deleted from this permit application. Corner guard on building must have a brushed stainless steel finish. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-069

HPA number
HPA 13-120
Property
Mixed-use – retail / residential
Description
Screening fence, gate, light fixture and address numbers
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed revisions to design to include address numbers on the brick pier by entrance gate, IPE fence and gates, and a new security light fixture as shown in supplemental drawings dated 25 January 2013. Fence and gates must be stained (solid). Light fixture matches previously approved fixture (see case OG 12-310). Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-072

HPA number
HPA 13-124
Property
Dumbarton Oaks Guest House
Description
Replacement windows on Guest House
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation
Recommend repair of original steel windows at historic Guest House.

OG 13-073

HPA number
HPA 13-125
Property
Dumbarton Oaks Guest House
Description
Guest House replacement slate roof
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for new gray-green slate roof to match existing with random width coursing and loose laid vertical gaps, and lead coated copper flashing. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-074

HPA number
HPA 13-127
Property
Dumbarton Oaks
Description
Operations Building replacement slate roof
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for new gray-green slate roof to match existing with random width coursing and loose laid vertical gaps, and lead coated copper flashing and trim, provided existing mechanical units are re-located to positions not visible from a public thoroughfare. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-075

HPA number
HPA 13-127
Property
Dumbarton Oaks
Description
Refectory replacement slate roof
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for new gray-green slate roof to match existing with random width coursing and loose laid vertical gaps, and lead coated copper flashing. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-076

HPA number
HPA 13-128
Property
Dumbarton Oaks
Description
New slate roof
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for new gray-green slate roof with random width coursing, loose laid vertical gaps and lead coated copper flashing. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-077

HPA number
HPA 13-129
Property
Commercial
Description
ADA ramp and signs
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation
No objection to concept design for ADA ramp with stone veneer and metal-mesh railing as shown in drawings dated 24 January 2013, provided signage on two windows does not include the registered trademark symbol or 'Early Education & Preschool,' also consider removal of brick pier. File new submission of working drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-078

HPA number
HPA 13-130
Property
Residence
Description
Replacement windows
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
Recommend against issuance of permit for removing existing windows. Submitted materials are not sufficient for review. File new submission of required information for replacement window proposals, including window survey, and existing and proposed details, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-079

HPA number
HPA 13-131
Property
Residence
Description
One-story rear addition of screened porch
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection of issuance of permit for new screen porch at rear with brick piers, flat seam metal roof, and beaded board side panels per supplemental drawings dated 14 February 2013. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-081

HPA number
HPA 13-133
Property
Commercial
Description
Light fixtures, alterations to sign scheme for 'Banana Republic'
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to issuance of permit for proposed repairs to facade and for alterations to sign scheme for 'Banana Republic', including new plaques and removal of lettering applied to glass on show windows. Recommend removal of gooseneck light fixtures and consideration of a back-lit sign pin-mounted to wall through mortar joints. Replacement light fixtures on projecting arms were not approved. Recommend wall sconce be sought to replace gooseneck light at rear door. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit. File a new submission of detailed and dimensioned drawings for back-lit sign with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-083

HPA number
HPA 13-135
Property
Commercial
Description
Alterations, sign scheme for 'The Frye Company'
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation

No objection to issuance of permit for 12" back-lit bronze letters reading 'The Frye Company' provided all mounting is through mortar and existing flag bracket is removed; also approved: two black fabric awnings, new wood doors and windows, operable shutters, and new HVAC on roof (not visible from public space) per supplemental drawings dated 13 February 2013. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-086

HPA number
HPA 13-138
Property
Residence
Description
Rear addition and alterations to fenestration, replacement roof, skylights
Review Type
Permit - revised design
Recommendation
The Commission regrets that rear chimney was demolished prior to review or permit. No objection to issuance of permit for proposed revisions to permit, including skylights, alterations to fenestration and replacement roof, as shown in supplemental drawings dated 13 February 2013 which indicate new metal standing seam roof matching spacing and details of existing terne roof, three equally spaced windows on second floor, and two windows matching smaller size of previously approved window on first floor. New roof must have seams hand-pressed to match original detailing. Removal of the chimney was not approved. Demolished chimney must be re-build using salvaged brick to match height and detailing of original chimney. Erect a material sample panel of both the approved Western red cedar siding and the proposed 5/8 inch thick Hardie Artisan Series lap siding, both painted, on site facing south, for review by the Old Georgetown Board prior to ordering materials. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-087

HPA number
HPA 13-139
Property
Residence
Description
1-story rear addition, alterations
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation
No objection to concept design to lengthen 1959 addition including frame projection provided portion of east wall of historic ell is maintained and addition is not toothed into existing walls, recommend proposed window lights are proportional to existing historic lights. File new submission of working drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-089

HPA number
HPA 13-141
Owner
D.C. Department of General Services
Property
D.C. Fire and Emergency Medical Services, Engine Company 5
Description
Alterations, replacement doors, repair/replace windows
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
Property is owned and managed by the District of Columbia Department of General Services and will be reviewed as a direct submission to the Commission of Fine Arts. See Direct Submission Consent Calendar, case number: CFA 21/FEB/13-f for recommended action. Refer to the DC Historic Preservation Office.

OG 13-091

HPA number
HPA 13-143
Property
Residence
Description
Replace ATM for 'BB&T Bank'
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation
No objection to the concept design for proposed dormer on rear slope of roof as shown in supplemental drawings dated 24 January 2013, which indicate roof of dormer below ridge of existing roof, and relocation of the rooftop mechanical equipment to rear yard. File new submission of working drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for review by the Commission.

OG 13-092

HPA number
HPA 13-101
Property
Bank
Description
Replace ATM for "BB&T Bank"
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed replacement of ATM as shown in supplemental drawings dated 7 February 2013 which indicate retention of grey aluminum surround and existing sign reading 'BB&T 24' on overhead cabinet. Note: Any subsequent modifications to the exterior design made during DCRA technical review must be re-submitted to the Commission for approval prior to issuance of permit.

OG 13-104

HPA number
HPA 13-180
Property
Residence
Description
1–story rear addition, replacement windows, alterations
Review Type
Permit
Recommendation

Returned without Action. Permit application for rear addition, replacement windows and alterations was withdrawn by written request of applicant.

OG 13-119

HPA number
HPA 13-182
Property
Residence
Description
Garage
Review Type
Concept
Recommendation

Returned without Action. Concept application for new garage was withdrawn by written request of applicant.